Biocurious is a weblog about biology, quantified.

Bill Bialek on theory in the age of Big Data

by Andre on 29 September 2014

One of the most talked about Big Data projects in the last year or so has been the BRAIN initiative in the US. It was prompted by the incredible advances that are being made in technologies to image and manipulate neural activity optically. In its early incarnation, the goal was to record the activity of every neuron in a brain over time. With Billions and Billions of neurons, that would most assuredly lead to a big pile of data.

In this context, Bill Bialek was invited to give some opening remarks on the second day of the Kavli/NSF symposium on the BRAIN initiative. Thankfully, they’ve made the video available, and it’s one of the most lucid expositions of the essential role that theory still plays in the age of Big Data that I’ve seen. He focusses on the brain and behaviour, but you could substitute cell biology and ‘omics without changing the message much.

Highlights from the talk:

Data mining [is] popular. But miners know gold when the see it. Theory is the source of explicit, testable hypotheses about what is golden in your data.

He goes on to make an important related point: even the algorithms you choose to apply represent implicit hypotheses about the data and strongly shape what you will find and how you will be able to interpret it.

If the goal is to explain behaviour in terms of neurons, synapses, molecules… we run the risk that the ingredients of explanation will outstrip the phenomena we are trying to explain.

So we need better quantitative characterisations of behaviour and better theories of what brains do.

Suppose I showed you a movie of what 10 000 water molecules are doing as the wander around in that liquid. I do not believe that by staring at hours of that movie you would ever induce the concept of wet. You can’t just look! It doesn’t work.

Bigger data will never solve this.



  1. Best essay writing service    282 days ago    #

    Nice post, I appreciated over read your weblog publish. Your blog have excellence figures, I were given right ideas from this outstanding blog. I am always looking like this kind weblog bring out. I’m hopeful I will see again. Thanks for contributing your important time to post such an interesting & useful collection of well-informed resources that are always of great need to everyone. Please keep continue sharing.


  2. Gclub    235 days ago    #

    While choosing best place online make note of the number of games provided in the website.

    m8bet

    รับแทงบอล

    sbobet mobile

    holiday palace

    ทางเข้า sbobet


  3. site    207 days ago    #

    good post.


  4.  Online Java Programming Homework Help     201 days ago    #

    I’m really impressed with your article, such great & usefull knowledge you mentioned here


  5. thesis writing service    189 days ago    #

    Thanks for sharing amazing information !!!!!!
    Please keep up sharing.


  6. Ragna Tiroks    147 days ago    #

    Thanks this is great topic i like it and i will share all this with my public fans on social media websites.


  7. home depot rubber flooring mats    133 days ago    #

    Halo Andre! This is a topic which is close to my heart… Best wishes! I am happy with your writing material thanks for sharing this post.


  8. Call Girls    126 days ago    #

    I really thank you for the valuable info on an excellent subject and look for more excellent content.


  9. gclub slot    124 days ago    #

    Nowadays, there are 20% of women who have urinary retention when doing daily activities such as coughing, laughing, or exercising. Which will make the girl The quality of life has deteriorated noticeably. Out of the home, emotions and feelings of fear or worry that the time of urination, urinating in the bathroom and urinate. These women are lack of confidence and do not dare to meet people because of the embarrassing that they have this.


  10. คาสิโนออนไลน์    90 days ago    #

    I’m hopeful I will see again. Thanks for contributing your important time to post such an interesting & useful collection of well-informed resources that are always of great need to everyone.


  11. casino online    88 days ago    #

    He goes on to make an important related point: even the algorithms you choose to apply represent implicit hypotheses about the data and strongly shape what you will find and how you will be able to interpret it.


  12. casinoonline th    88 days ago    #

    Nowadays, there are 20% of women who have urinary retention when doing daily activities such as coughing, laughing, or exercising. Which will make the girl The quality of life has deteriorated noticeably.


  13. casino onlineth    88 days ago    #

    Out of the home, emotions and feelings of fear or worry that the time of urination, urinating in the bathroom and urinate.


  14. th casinoonline    88 days ago    #

    These women are lack of confidence and do not dare to meet people because of the embarrassing that they have this.


  15. th casino    88 days ago    #

    Nice post, I appreciated over read your weblog publish. Your blog have excellence figures, I were given right ideas from this outstanding blog.


  16. adobetonline casino    88 days ago    #

    I am always looking like this kind weblog bring out. I’m hopeful I will see again.


  17. adobet casino    88 days ago    #

    Thanks for contributing your important time to post such an interesting & useful collection of well-informed resources that are always of great need to everyone.


  18. sbobet facebook    88 days ago    #

    If the goal is to explain behaviour in terms of neurons, synapses, molecules… we run the risk that the ingredients of explanation will outstrip the phenomena we are trying to explain.


  19. sbobet fb    88 days ago    #

    So we need better quantitative characterisations of behaviour and better theories of what brains do.


  20. crossword susa    88 days ago    #

    Suppose I showed you a movie of what 10 000 water molecules are doing as the wander around in that liquid.


  21. thaicasinoonline casino    88 days ago    #

    I do not believe that by staring at hours of that movie you would ever induce the concept of wet. You can’t just look! It doesn’t work.


  22. Baccarat inth    88 days ago    #

    While choosing best place online make note of the number of games provided in the website.


  23. Baccarat inthai    88 days ago    #

    and it’s one of the most lucid expositions of the essential role that theory still plays in the age of Big Data that I’ve seen.


  24. Zean Baccarat    88 days ago    #

    Data mining [is] popular. But miners know gold when the see it. Theory is the source of explicit, testable hypotheses about what is golden in your data.


  25. Zean Baccaratth    88 days ago    #

    He focusses on the brain and behaviour, but you could substitute cell biology and ‘omics without changing the message much.


  26. 365bet casinoonline    88 days ago    #

    One of the most talked about Big Data projects in the last year or so has been the BRAIN initiative in the US.


  27. 365bet casino    88 days ago    #

    It was prompted by the incredible advances that are being made in technologies to image and manipulate neural activity optically.


  28. 365 casinoonline    88 days ago    #

    In its early incarnation, the goal was to record the activity of every neuron in a brain over time.


  29. gclub 24th    88 days ago    #

    He goes on to make an important related point: even the algorithms you choose to apply represent implicit hypotheses about the data and strongly shape what you will find and how you will be able to interpret it.


  30. gclub th    88 days ago    #

    So we need better quantitative characterisations of behaviour and better theories of what brains do.


  31. ความงาม    82 days ago    #

    Hi there to all, how is everything, I think every one is getting more
    from this site, and your views are good in favor of new visitors.


  32. Dissertation Writing Help    68 days ago    #

    I Appreciate Your Efforts In Preparing This Post. I Really Like Your Blog Articles.


  33. gmail account login    40 days ago    #

    Thanks this is great topic i like it and i will share all this with my public fans on social media websites.


  34. gcrb    36 days ago    #

    I had been wondering if your web host is OK? Not that I am complaining, but slow loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement
    in google and could damage your high quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords.
    Well I am adding this RSS to my email and could
    look out for much more of your respective fascinating content.
    Ensure that you update this again very soon.


  35. gcrb    36 days ago    #

    It’s enough to make the wish that is discerning that Ice Age would pull a Minions and
    make these sidekick pratfalls the main attraction.


  36. gcrb    36 days ago    #

    While choosing best place online make note of the number of games provided in the website.


  37. gcrb    36 days ago    #

    He goes on to make an important related point: even the algorithms you choose to apply represent implicit hypotheses about the data and strongly shape what you will find and how you will be able to interpret it.


  38. gcrb    36 days ago    #

    I Appreciate Your Efforts In Preparing This Post. I Really Like Your Blog Articles.


Name
Email
http://
Message
  Textile help